Pork and Bell Pepper Pie (Page 77)
RECIPE #965
- Date: Tuesday, March 3, 2009 -- 7pm
- Location: Bloomington, IN
- Kitchen: My Apartment
- Fellow Chef: Matty
- Dining Companions: Mike M, Teresa, Matty, Lars, and Andrew
- Recipe Rating: B
This recipe isn't online.
Math is a very precise thing, and mathematicians tend to be very careful about what they say. Accuracy is important in math, and even in everyday conversation most mathematicians are very careful to only make claims that they are sure about. I realize this about math people, and as a consequence when a mathematician disagrees with me, I often assume that I am wrong, even if I am not. I know this about myself, but it struck me the other day that maybe this is a bad thing. Here's what happened:
I was at a conference and it was someone's birthday. The organizers went out and bought a bunch of cake. One of the cakes was Red Velvet and that's the one I headed toward when it was time to eat. Someone near me in line for cake asked what Red Velvet cake tastes like. I responded, "It's tastes a bit chocolatey because it has cocoa in it." Another person present "corrected" me, "No it doesn't," he said, "It's just white cake that they dye red with food coloring." He was right that Red Velvet cake often has red food coloring, but wrong about the cocoa. Any reasonably traditional Red Velvet Cake has cocoa in it -- in particular the one we ate that evening certainly did. A reaction between the cocoa and the acidity of either buttermilk or vinegar (two other common Red Velvet ingredients) causes a slightly reddish color that was thought to have inspired the addition of the food coloring. I know all this. I have made Red Velvet cake. But here's the thing that is bothering me. Not only did I not stand up to him, but I assumed I must be mistaken. He's a really smart guy, and he was making a claim with confidence. So I assumed I was wrong. Later, back in my room, I looked it up. The fact that I had been right only made me angry -- not at him, he's a perfectly nice guy -- but rather at myself. There was no need to correct him, but I should have at least believed that I was right! If it had been a conversation about anything else, it would have been excuseable, but this was a conversation about cake! I love cake. I know a lot about cake. There was no reason to doubt myself.
Something to work on...

3 comments:
With regards to red velvet cake, yes, of course, you are right that red velvet has some cocoa powder.
In another sense, though, the guy was right in that I have pretty much never actually tasted any chocolate-y flavor in any red velvet cake or cupcake I've had. They probably all have some cocoa powder, but pretty much every red velvet cake I've had tastes like nothing (except for the cream cheese frosting, which is what makes it delicious!).
I know what you mean - even just a BS in math was enough to train me to be very careful about what I claim I 'know'. Glad to hear it's not just me.
In my experience Red Velvet cakes made in the South seem to have more chocolate flavor than those up North. In particular the one I ate in North Carolina had a nice chocolate flavor to it!
Liz: Yeah, studying math gives you a whole new perspective on what it means to "know" things.
Post a Comment